The purpose of the E. Urner Goodman Scholarship program was to assist members of the Order of the Arrow who are preparing for a professional Scouting career. Grants were provided to help fulfill the financial obligations of their college education.
The National Order of the Arrow committee established the scholarship fund as a meaningful living memorial to the founder of the Order and to help perpetuate recruitment of high-caliber, service-minded individuals dedicated to professional Scouting service.
E. Urner Goodman, founder of the Order of the Arrow, was a teacher before entering the professional service of the Boy Scouts of America in 1915. He retired as national director of Program in 1951. Dr Goodman believed strongly that a professional career in Scouting provided an excellent method of serving one's fellow man.
| Year | Name | Lodge | Hometown |
| 2000 | Mark F. Hogan | Tisquantum Lodge | Canton, Massachusetts |
| 2000 | Andrew V. Zahn | Cho-Gun-Mun-A-Nock Lodge | Cedar Rapids, Iowa |
| 2000 | Brock C. Ostrander | Yah-Tah-Hey-Si-Kess Lodge | Albuquerque, New Mexico |
| 2001 | Andrew V. Zahn | Cho-Gun-Mun-A-Nock Lodge | Cedar Rapids, Iowa |
| 2001 | Seth Hill | Coosa Lodge | Birmingham, Alabama |
| 2001 | Roberto Fernandez III | O-Shot-Caw Lodge | Miami, Florida |
| 2002 | Christopher Cairnes | Loon Lodge | Plattsburgh, New York |
| 2002 | Homer Dearmin | Wahissa Lodge | Winston-Salem, North Carolina |
| 2002 | Phillip Seth Hill | Coosa Lodge | Birmingham, Alabama |
| 2002 | Brock Ostrander | Yah-Tah-Hey-Si-Kess Lodge | Albuquerque, New Mexico |
| 2003 | Gilbert R. Rogers | Tschitani Lodge | East Hartford, Connecticut |
| 2003 | Tristan J. Blease | Mawatt Woakus Lodge | Findlay, Ohio |
| 2003 | Christopher A. Heuchert | Waun a LaMon'tay Lodge | Portland, Oregon |
| 2004 | Christopher A. Heuchert | Waun a LaMon'tay Lodge | Portland, Oregon |
| 2004 | Gilbert R. Rogers | Tschitani Lodge | East Hartford, CT |
| 2004 | Justin M. Stirewalt | Wahissa Lodge | Winston Salem, NC |
| 2004 | Jack Temsey | Sippo Lodge | Canton, Ohio |
| 2004 | John E. Thomas | Talidandaganu Lodge | Chattanooga, TN |